Holy Cow
People were shocked that I had chosen to stay in a place as Rameswaram. I was at loss to understand how a place of pilgrimage was not to be obvious and chosen as a place to live. Though I found the concerns unwarranted and the people really nice and simple; yet this stay gave me a deeper understanding of the development of cultures.
My friend sought to clarify; he narrated the incident where a bus load of pilgrims had come to the holy place of Rameswaram in the scorching summer heat of the month of June.
Rameswaram can be very hot throughout the year and in the monsoon it is flooded with sea water, largely and therefore mosquitoes rule. Not surprising that Lord Rama used to stay at Ramanathpuram even though he launched and supervised all the attacks at Sri Lanka from Rameswaram where he worshipped the Supreme Lord Rameswar.
As the people were haggling and trying to get a decent price for the tender coconut water and the seller trying to get the best of the opportunity. Towards the end, as the bus was about to start a small child sprang from nowhere and snatched a coconut from the cart and made good his escape; but was noticed by one of the bystanders, who raised the alarm. By that time the bus had started but this only really further infuriated the seller. Who chased and stopped the bus not realizing that he was still carrying the knife he used to scale and peel the coconut with; he pulled out the child and before realizing what he was doing he in his fit of frenzy chopped of the hands of the child.
Hands of a child!! Howsoever naughty it may be; for a coconut that would not cost more than four to six rupees (those days)?
Howsoever valid may be the point of the child who may have not realised what he was doing (a bulk of coconuts was coming in the bus and the child may have never realised that it had been bargained and paid for and just wanted one for himself too).
Or, the man who was more mad at the situations of life that he faced, for whom the coconuts were much more than source of returns. They were his only means to a dignified living. Those who are aware of a fishermans life know for well that a fishermans life can be a very exploited one; at home, at sea, in the family, village or the market. One who has to stay away for days leaving his family at the mercy of creditors, land lords, village heads, the rich and the so called social guardians who more often than not exploit the family in very possible way as if it was an obligation and a matter of right.
The sea which may not necessarily reward the efforts of the poor group of fisherman; the boat would not be his –most of the times. The market, which may not pay the right remuneration for the hard and risky venture and efforts of the poor man. The product itself being perishable left the poor people with very few choices than to accept and suffer the vagaries of life; as also hardening them about the sensitivities of a social amicability sometimes.
No wonder that this coconut which many a times a very important source of existence and thriving social order attracts a range of laws; unbelievable for a community that sees the fruit only in temples or sweet shops.
The picking up of a coconut even if it lying in your own fields is a punishable crime since it never fell from your tree; and is the source of bread butter and a dignified living for a person to whom it belongs and who cannot practically stand under the tree waiting for the coconut to mature. The whole social economy thrives around this tree, professionals who tend it, clean it, defruit it. Use its leaves for thatching and constructing homes, the wood, the husky covering, the fruit in its various stages –tender, ripe, or dry. The uses of Coir, Copra, and as a source of oil. Any law related to this fruit would make sense to this community.
You must be wondering, why do I have to say all this and what am I trying to get at? Well having been through all of the above realities and having accepted the logic behind the evolved systems. One fine morning I overheard one of these people innocently make a statement –more of a declaration, about cows; and that it is not that whole of India treated cows as sacred, or did not eat beef.
The first point I can accept, that yes the whole of the country does not necessarily treat the cow as sacred and it is particularly the Vedic tradition that has upheld the stand that the cow is sacred and is to be protected even if at the cost of ones life. Though it is true that we in the north have lost at least one war (against Babar), due to the rigid adherence to this law. Yet try to understand this from the point of view where we have evolved through systems that imposed social order and laws through religious sanctions.
Vedic systems particularly bloomed on the fertile lands along the rivers. Whether north or south. South particularly, never really has had a vibrant milk economy. Yet North has always been dependent on cows; whether it be for milk, curd, butter, cream, Ghee, sweets or even oxen to help cover distances or plough fields. So much so that the knowledge of yoga which is also the most important art of living life and the single most great contribution for the social development now and in the days to come uses service to domestic animals and especially the cow for developing sensitivity. The fact can be well gauged from the fact that a lamp with sesame seed oil is very sacrosanct but in the north it is the Ghee lamp, which is also considered as the best for the practice of Tratak on the flame, next only to the honey bee wax. The accessibility to the marauding and hostile tribes further gave the cows (which would be major food providers in case of destruction of all crops) as also the feminine gender (which was also the most important and key player in animal husbandry) a protected status; to the extent that hunting of feminine gender was always looked down upon in developed societies; therefore one can find Cocks, male Goats, male Boars, male Deers etc being slaughtered or hunted for food never the feminine genders. In case of an accidental hunt the kill would be left for the tribesmen and drummers who accompanied the hunting parties or skinned the kill; may sound hollow to some yet this was the social sanction to help maintain and uphold discipline and the basic idea as well as ensure nothing was wasted. Though in the long run the better off and socially conscious among these began to follow and uphold the same discipline to gain respect and status both from their employers as well as their own kin.
Rules were centered more around the usefulness of the animals and birds and optimum utilization of resources and not merely on taste or passion. The food collectors (not growers), tribals, wanderers and such people never accepted or conformed to such laws unless they tried to be as respectable.
With the globalization and developed mode of transport, the accelerated material growth and the mushrooming tourism industry; the logic behind this evolved system may be lost to many a people who may never have been exposed to a culture so rich and deep.
Yet this cannot be a reason, for, either enforcing a belief that which may not be applicable, nor downplaying any idea without understanding the depth of the logic behind it. It is not important what is being done but how come it came it into existence; and does the logic still apply? It would be fair to say that no one has given cow as much importance and protection compared to the coconut. You may not be able to see the point, yet, this is how I feel.
Perhaps the only other equivalent example is that of the Bisnoi's of Rajasthan who have even braved the axes and swords to ensure that the trees of their courtyard and forests were not felled; who could better understand the need for the trees other than those who were directly affected by the advancing sandy deserts and the falling water levels. Who can better understand this than those who have one single chore the whole day; that is to go and get water for the family, Five hours walking to the well and about the same back, certainly not one who keeps moving where the water goes or the one who stays right next to the large sweet drinkable water rivers.
In the end I wish to add that I stayed in Rameswaram for about a month at least as a guest of a Swami staying on the road to Dhanushkothi from a well known order; and he used to support three or five odd villages to help them achieve their rights. The hospitality was unparalleled.
Tuesday, April 24, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
Yes The American love their Horses; wonder what would Europe think of Horse Eating people. Not that I suggest it. But perhaps this would reflect the sentiments of Non Cow Eating Indians best. The attachment and gratitude that builds up cannot be measured by words and can only be seen in attitude
Post a Comment